Closeboard vs Panel Fencing: Which Is Right for Your Garden in Chichester?
If you’re replacing or installing a new fence, one of the most common questions homeowners ask is whether closeboard fencing or panel fencing is the better option.
Both are widely used across Chichester and surrounding villages — but they perform very differently depending on wind exposure, budget, and how long you want the fence to last.
This guide compares closeboard vs panel fencing, explains the pros and cons of each, and helps you choose the right option for your garden.
What’s the Difference Between Closeboard and Panel Fencing?
Closeboard (Feather Edge) Fencing
Closeboard fencing is built on site, using individual overlapping vertical boards fixed to horizontal rails.
It’s known for:
Strength and durability
Excellent performance in wind
Long lifespan
Traditional appearance
Panel Fencing
Panel fencing uses pre-made fence panels slotted between posts.
It’s popular because:
It’s quicker to install
It has a lower upfront cost
It offers a clean, uniform look
Which Fence Is Better for Windy Gardens?
In exposed areas around West Sussex, closeboard fencing is usually the better choice.
Why?
Boards can flex slightly rather than failing
Load is spread across rails and posts
Concrete posts pair exceptionally well with closeboard fencing
Panel fencing often acts like a sail in strong winds, which is why panels are commonly the first thing to fail during storms.
To read more about the best fencing for windy gardens, click here.
Repairs: Closeboard vs Panels
Closeboard Repairs
individual boards can be easily replaced.
Cheaper long-term maintenance
Less disruption
the rails can be replaced using metal brackets.
Panel Repairs
Damaged panels usually need full replacement
Can become costly after repeated storms
Less forgiving of poor ground conditions
panels slide in/slide out, but shrubs/tree growth can cause problems long term.
any long term movement of the posts can make new panel replacement difficult.
For homeowners planning to stay put, closeboard fencing often works out cheaper over time.
Appearance & Style Considerations
Closeboard fencing:
Traditional look
Can be stained or painted
Works well with both modern and older properties
Panel fencing:
Cleaner, more uniform appearance
Available in decorative styles
Suits sheltered gardens and budget projects
To see more examples of our work and to get in touch, please click here for our fencing page.
